By-Election 13 December 2017 (resulting from the resignation of Simon Thornton)
| Godalming – Central & Ockford Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| BENNEWITH, Graham Joshua | The Conservative Party | 252 |
| CURTIS, Lewis Michael | The Labour Party | 162 |
| FOLLOWS, Paul David | Liberal Democrats | 294 Elected |
By-Election 4 May 2017 (resulting from the resignation of Frank Young)
| Godalming – Binscombe Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| FOLLOWS, Paul David | Liberal Democrats | 400 |
| PARK, Robert | Labour Party | 212 |
| WAINWRIGHT, Richard James Gordon | The Conservative Party | 474 Elected |
By-Election 11 February 2016 (resulting from the resignation of Joy Woodham)
| Godalming – Central & Ockford Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| CURTIS, Lewis | The Labour Party | 162 |
| GREEN, David Myles | The Conservative Party | 303 |
| PURKISS, Oliver William | Liberal Democrats | 328 Elected |
Ordinary Elections 7 May 2015
| Godalming – Binscombe Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| GRAY, Margaret Anne | The Conservative Party | 775 Elected |
| HULLAH, Heather | Liberal Democrats | 765 |
| HUNTER, David Malcolm | The Conservative Party | 900 Elected |
| WHEATLEY, Liz | The Conservative Party | 833 Elected |
| WILLIAMS, Stephen Edward Dalton | The Labour Party | 714 |
| YOUNG, Frank | The Conservative Party | 806 Elected |
| Godalming – Central & Ockford Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| BOLTON, Andrew John Campbell | The Conservative Party | 1,154 Elected |
| DAVIES, George Adam | The Labour Party | 765 |
| PINCHES, Nick | The Conservative Party | 874 Elected |
| ROBINSON, Paul James | Something New | 628 |
| THORNTON, Simon David | The Conservative Party | 1,047 Elected |
| WILLIS, Jenny | Liberal Democrats | 868 |
| WOODHAM, Joy Edith | The Conservative Party | 954 Elected |
| Godalming – Charterhouse Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| COSSER, Steve | The Conservative Party | 1,085 Elected |
| GORDON-SMITH, Tony | The Conservative Party | 1,162 Elected |
| GRIFFITHS, Eleanor | The Labour Party | 629 |
| POULTER, Joy Mary | The Conservative Party | 1,136 Elected |
| REYNOLDS, Stefan Nicholas | The Conservative Party | 1,021 Elected |
| ROBINSON, Rebecca Anne Nahrae | Something New | 447 |
| Godalming – Farncombe & Catteshall Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| BARNES, Jenny | Liberal Democrats | 699 |
| HAVERON, Patrick Kennedy | Liberal Democrats | 476 |
| NOYCE, Julie Elizabeth | The Conservative Party | 1,142 Elected |
| PARK, Robert | The Labour Party | 602 |
| RIVERS, Paul Sidney | Liberal Democrats | 693 |
| RIVERS, Penny | Liberal Democrats | 871 |
| WALDEN, Kirsty Anne | The Conservative Party | 1,061 Elected |
| WELLAND, Ross Adrian | The Conservative Party | 1,037 Elected |
| WILLIAMS, Michael Richard | The Labour Party | 595 |
| WILLIAMS, Nick | The Conservative Party | 1,060 Elected |
| Godalming – Holloway Ward | ||
| Name of Candidate | Description | Number of Votes |
| BOTT, Anne Maree | The Conservative Party | 1,552 Elected |
| BOTT, Steve | The Conservative Party | 1,423 Elected |
| MARTIN, Peter James | The Conservative Party | 1,712 Elected |
| MARTIN, Tom | The Conservative Party | 1,594 Elected |
| PULLEN, Luis Simon | The Labour Party | 789 |